Honestly it is more a miss for me. I do not have severe problems with my lips so maybe I'm not the target audience. I needed something for occasional dryness and for soothing after exfoliating. I do like the smell and it's very economical, a little goes a long way. The little spatula that comes with it is convenient since you need a small amount of product. But as a night mask it's like... whatever. It is tacky and in the morning I feel like my lips are stuck to each other (not a nice feeling at all). Maybe it will perform better in the winter. For now I'm going to use it as a day time balm. I probably won't repurchase. I dont even know if I'm going to finish this jar.