I got #3 tint mint since it's created by Lee Sung Kyung (weightlifting fairy anyone?) and I was deciding between that or #8 cherry milk since this lip bar is not exactly inexpensive. I saw a few videos on youtube to see what I would be getting, and thought that color pay-off was not that great. However, I received the product today and tried it, and the color pay-off was more than I expected! The tint part is actually really obvious, and the moisturizing balm-like part really helps with my dry lips. The product smells like candy too! Overall, I can see myself purchasing more!