#9 is An orange lip product gives a more fresh and lively look I think. I've been doing an old school gradient and a soft overdrawing and I like it both ways as long as I blank out or color correct my lips at least a little bit. It shows up and is beautiful on my medium skin complexion so that's always a plus, I'm glad I took the leap with the new color line. I'm not sure if it would show up on deeper complexions but I hope my picture helps, I hope they make even more daring and varied colors everyone can enjoy (including me..I am a new fan)

*a note on both ones I got is that the product smells of fruity flowers. it could be cloying to someone who's sensitive to smell, but it is a nice break from the overdrying liquid lipsticks I have.