I have tried many types of brush liners, they are my favorite type of eyeliner.  My previous HG one was a Japanese brand, but recently I noticed it started to dry out very fast.  I've been looking for my new favorite brush liner ever since, particularly in the brown shade, since this color tends to look less harsh on my eyes.  I have been very pleased with this Clio liner!  The tip is perfectly precise, and the shade of brown is just right (not too dark or too light).  The liner is very waterproof, doesn't irritate or smudge. It comes off easily with oil cleanser, or the mini remover that is included with this set. I am very happy to call this my new replacement HG liner.