I was looking for a pencil liner to use for tight lining my upper lash line.  I have tried so many brands for this purpose, but I still hadn't found the perfect one yet.  This pencil is so far my winner!  I ordered it in the brown shade, which is true to the color in the website pictures. I am very pleased with this liner. It is a retractable mechanical type of pencil, which I prefer. It goes on smooth, doesn't smudge and doesn't irritate my eyes! Most importantly, it doesn't transfer to my lower lash line, which so many liners do to me!  I'm so happy I took a chance on this liner.  Curious to try it in black next time. Just for reference, the tip on this liner is not very precise, so if you are looking to make sharp lines, this may not be the best option, but for my purpose, it was great.