This is the first time I use a Cleansing Stick. I bought this one because I really liked their toner. This cleansing stick is amazing as an oil based cleanser, takes off makeup like a dream. The scent is herbal (very light) the little black specks do not irritate my skin. The balm is super smooth and glides over my skin. When it comes in contact with water the balm emulsifies very nicely taking off everything. Sadly, I never saw this become a true cleansing foam (sometimes a couple of bubbles appeared). I don't know if it's me although I have tried different methods of using but I never get this to become a foam and becoming the third step they say.